--- title: Disillusioned About MIPS Incentives? Here’s Why You Shouldn’t Be. description: MIPS is budget neutral, which means that high participation rates and high performance have the effect of decreasing the overall budget pool for positive payment adjustments. That’s why in the first performance year for MIPS, even though the maximum incentive and penalty adjustment was 22%, the actual adjustment ended up at a comparatively paltry 1.88%. image: https://blog.healthmonix.com/hubfs/Stock%20Images%201200%20x%20628/sad.jpg --- ![logo-light](https://blog.healthmonix.com/hubfs/logo-light.png "logo-light") - [Who we help](https://healthmonix.com/who-we-help/) - [Overview](https://healthmonix.com/who-we-help/) - [ACOs](https://healthmonix.com/acos/) - [Health systems](https://healthmonix.com/health-system/) - [Healthcare technology](https://healthmonix.com/healthcare-technology/) - [Physician practices](https://healthmonix.com/physician-practice/) - [Health system VPs](https://healthmonix.com/health-system-vice-presidents/) - [Chief financial officers](https://healthmonix.com/chief-financial-officers/) - [Chief medical officers](https://healthmonix.com/chief-medical-officers/) - [Chief quality officers](https://healthmonix.com/chief-quality-officers/) - [ACO executive directors](https://healthmonix.com/aco-executive-directors/) - [Solutions](https://healthmonix.com/prism/) - [MIPSpro](https://healthmonix.com/product/mips-pro/) - [Cost](https://healthmonix.com/product/cost/) - [ACO Impact](https://healthmonix.com/product/aco-impact/) - [Analytics](https://healthmonix.com/product/analytics/) - [Ambulatory Specialty Model](https://healthmonix.com/ambulatory-specialty-model-asm/) - [TEAM](https://healthmonix.com/team-program/) - [HealthConnect](https://healthmonix.com/health-connect/) - [Data integration](https://healthmonix.com/dataintegration/) - [Consulting](https://healthmonix.com/consulting-services/) - [Score optimization](https://healthmonix.com/score-optimization/) - [Patient matching](https://healthmonix.com/patient-deduplication-and-matching/) - [Outcomes](https://healthmonix.com/outcomes/) - [Company](https://healthmonix.com/company/) - [Our story](https://healthmonix.com/company/) - [Team](https://healthmonix.com/team/) - [Careers](https://healthmonix.com/healthmonix-careers/) - [Resources](https://healthmonix.com/resources/) - [Help and support](https://healthmonix.com/customer-support/) - [Healthmonix Advisor](https://blog.healthmonix.com/) - [Webinars](https://healthmonix.com/our-webinars/) - [Educational resources](https://healthmonix.com/mips-education/) - [Help and support](https://healthmonix.com/customer-support/) - [Contact us](https://healthmonix.com/contact-us/) - [Measures](https://healthmonix.com/mips-measures/) - [Quality](https://healthmonix.com/mips-measures/mips-quality-measures/) - [CMS specialty sets](https://healthmonix.com/cms-mips-specialty-measure-sets/) - [Promoting Interoperability](https://healthmonix.com/mips-measures/mips-promoting-interoperability-measures/) - [Improvement Activities](https://healthmonix.com/mips-measures/mips-improvement-activities/) - [Cost](https://healthmonix.com/mips-measures/mips-cost-performance-category/) - [Log in](https://healthmonix.com/login/) # Healthmonix Advisor # Disillusioned About MIPS Incentives? Here’s Why You Shouldn’t Be. Posted by [Christina Zink](https://blog.healthmonix.com/author/christina-zink) on January 11, 2019 ![](https://app.hubspot.com/settings/avatar/1e386ff4e65c2b2e78f1dd6f6c67a86d) Find me on: [LinkedIn](https://www.linkedin.com/in/christina-zink-062b4457) - [Tweet](https://twitter.com/share) ![sad](https://blog.healthmonix.com/hubfs/Stock%20Images%201200%20x%20628/sad.jpg) If your organization invested significant money and time into achieving a high MIPS score in 2017, the final incentive payment you received may have felt… well, disappointing. As easy as it may be to recognize the ideological importance of shifting from fee-for-service to value-based care, many clinicians and organizations feel unable to practically justify such an investment in the absence of a meaningful financial incentive. But there’s good news: incentives will continue to rise in coming years, and those achieving the highest scores will soon find their efforts rewarded on a much larger scale. Here’s why. #### **Why Incentives Were Low in 2017** MIPS is budget neutral, which means that high participation rates and high performance have the effect of decreasing the overall budget pool for positive payment adjustments. That’s why in the first performance year for MIPS, even though the maximum incentive and penalty adjustment was 22% (when taking into account maximum scaling factor and exceptional performance bonuses), the actual adjustment ended up at a paltry 1.88%. CMS has made serious efforts to account for industry input and reduce administrative burden. These efforts seemed fruitful this year as they [announced](https://www.cms.gov/blog/quality-payment-program-qpp-year-1-performance-results) an unexpectedly high participation rate, exceeding their goal of 90% overall, and hitting 98% for ACOs and 94% for rural practices. But because performance thresholds were artificially lowered to 3 points, which could be acquired through any submission at all, participating in and passing MIPS was easy.   #### **What Will Change Moving Forward** [**![mips-payment-adjustments](https://blog.healthmonix.com/hs-fs/hubfs/mips-payment-adjustments.png?width=700&name=mips-payment-adjustments.png)**](https://blog.healthmonix.com/hubfs/mips-payment-adjustments.jpg)  This year, though, MIPS won’t be so easy. In the final rule for 2018, CMS predicts that only 74% of clinicians will earn a score higher than 70%. The minimum threshold rises to 15 points, and in 2019 it will rise again to 30 points. In 2020 it’s predicted to rise even further, to 45 points. Because of this, and also because of the increasing weight of the Cost category and the increased difficulty of the Promoting Interoperability category, submission alone won’t be enough to pass, and overall success will be harder to achieve with each passing year. **Consequently, that 1.88% incentive rate will certainly rise.** | **Performance Year** | **Payment Year** | **Max penalty** | **Max incentive via Policy** | **Predicted Actual Max Incentive** | | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | | 2017 | 2019 | 4% | **22%** = (4% \* 0.1-3% scaling factor) + 0.5-10% additional performance threshold | 1.88% (*actual*) | | 2018 | 2020 | 5% | **25%** = (5% \* 0.1-3% scaling factor) + 0.5-10% additional performance threshold | 2.05% | | 2019 | 2021 | 7% | **31%** = (7% \* 0.1-3% scaling factor) + 0.5-10% additional performance threshold | 4.69% | | 2020 | 2022 | 9% | **37%** = (9% \* 0.1-3% scaling factor) + 0.5-10% additional performance threshold | 10%+  (*accuracy to increase after 2020 proposed rule*) |   So if your organization has invested in MIPS and is currently feeling discouraged by the returns, just keep in mind that as penalties and incentives continue to increase, your preparation will ultimately put you farther and farther ahead of those who chose (and continue to choose) to do the minimum.     Topics: [PRO Tips](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/pro-tips), [MACRA & MIPS](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/macra-mips), [Policy](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/policy), [ROI](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/roi) ### Subscribe Here! ### Search the Healthmonix Advisor - [MACRA & MIPS (132)](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/macra-mips) - [Policy (77)](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/policy) - [PRO Tips (57)](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/pro-tips) - [CMS (34)](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/cms) - [Quality Performance Category (32)](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/quality-performance-category) - [Industry insights (29)](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/industry-insights) - [VBC (20)](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/vbc) - [ACO (19)](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/aco) - [Healthmonix (19)](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/healthmonix) - [MIPS Reporting (19)](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/mips-reporting) - [Cost Performance Category (16)](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/cost-performance-category) - [Health IT (16)](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/health-it) - [APMs (15)](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/apms) - [Eligibility (15)](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/eligibility) - [Interoperability (14)](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/interoperability) - [Value-Based Care (14)](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/value-based-care) - [IA Performance Category (11)](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/ia-performance-category) - [ROI (11)](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/roi) - [COVID-19 (10)](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/covid-19) - [ACI Performance Category (9)](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/aci-performance-category) - [EHR (9)](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/ehr) - [PQRS (9)](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/pqrs) - [APM Performance Pathway (7)](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/apm-performance-pathway) - [Hospitals & Health Systems (7)](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/hospitals-health-systems) - [MIPS CQMs (7)](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/mips-cqms) - [PI Performance Category (6)](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/pi-performance-category) - [Bundled Payments (5)](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/bundled-payments) - [MIPS Value Pathways (5)](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/mips-value-pathways) - [Small Practice (5)](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/small-practice) - [2021 PFS Proposed Rule (4)](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/2021-pfs-proposed-rule) - [Accountable Care Organization (4)](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/accountable-care-organization) - [Conference (4)](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/conference) - [Physician Compare (4)](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/physician-compare) - [2022 PFS Final Rule (3)](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/2022-pfs-final-rule) - [APG (3)](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/apg) - [Administrative Burden (3)](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/administrative-burden) - [RCM (3)](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/rcm) - [certified electronic health record technology (3)](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/certified-electronic-health-record-technology) - [eCQMs (3)](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/ecqms) - [2015 Edition CEHRT (2)](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/2015-edition-cehrt) - [2021 PFS Final Rule (2)](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/2021-pfs-final-rule) - [2022 PFS Proposed Rule (2)](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/2022-pfs-proposed-rule) - [2023 PFS Final Rule (2)](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/2023-pfs-final-rule) - [2023 Proposed Rule (2)](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/2023-proposed-rule) - [AI (2)](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/ai) - [Medicare Shared Savings Program (2)](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/medicare-shared-savings-program) - [Merit-based Incentive Payment System (2)](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/merit-based-incentive-payment-system) - [Promoting Interoperability (2)](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/promoting-interoperability) - [health equity (2)](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/health-equity) - [healthcare (2)](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/healthcare) - [2015 (1)](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/2015) - [2015 Edition Cures Update (1)](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/2015-edition-cures-update) - [2015 Edition Cures Update certification (1)](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/2015-edition-cures-update-certification) - [2023 MIPS Reporting for Large Practices (1)](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/2023-mips-reporting-for-large-practices) - [ACCESS (1)](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/access) - [AMGA (1)](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/amga) - [Gaps in Care - New Quality Measures (1)](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/gaps-in-care-new-quality-measures) - [Health Equity Adjustment (1)](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/health-equity-adjustment) - [Improvement Activities (1)](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/improvement-activities) - [MIPS Cost (1)](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/mips-cost) - [MVPs (1)](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/mvps) - [NPPES (1)](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/nppes) - [Practice Reopening (1)](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/practice-reopening) - [Primary Care First (1)](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/primary-care-first) - [Strategic Health IT Partnerships (1)](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/strategic-health-it-partnerships) - [billing companies (1)](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/billing-companies) - [submission (1)](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/submission) - [universal foundation of quality measures (1)](https://blog.healthmonix.com/topic/universal-foundation-of-quality-measures) see all Search ### Recent Posts ## Outcomes focused: Improving the quality and delivery of care ![logo-icon](https://blog.healthmonix.com/hubfs/logo-icon.png "logo-icon") © 2024 Healthmonix. All Rights Reserved.